Trip Report: Middle Palisade 15-16 August 2009
Posted in Uncategorized on August 27th, 2009 by bpope – 4 CommentsBackground reading: YDS grading (see 3rd and 4th class)
For future climbers: check out the galleries or flickr set for images of maps and pictures with our route drawn in.
After successfully making it up both Mt. Whitney and Mt. Shasta, I turned my sights towards another of California’s 14ers. I bought Porcella and Burns’ “Climbing California’s Fourteeners” and pored over it, trying to identify a mountain and route that would be both doable and exciting. Immediately Mt. Williamson and Mt. Tyndall looked really fun, but they are closed for most of the year (big horn sheep). The next thing that caught my eye was Thunderbolt Peak, specifically its 5.8+ summit block. A close second was Middle Pal, which looked like a great hike over varied terrain, with awesome alpine lakes along the way. I couldn’t decide, but the Inyo National Forest quota system decided for me…no reservable permits for Thunderbolt, but plenty of space on the way to Middle Pal.
Sweet. All that was left was actually figuring out where to camp and which trail to hike, right? After picking up our wilderness permit via “nightbox” service at the White Mountain Ranger Station, Kurt and I stayed at Sage Flat Campground, just west of Big Pine, on Friday night, rolling in at about 1:30am. We slept in until about 9 before driving just a little further up the road to the parking lot labeled “Trailhead Parking.” It occurred to me then that I really didn’t know much about the trail we were supposed to take, except that it was called the South fork of Big Pine Creek. I also knew we were taking the “East Face” route detailed by Porcella and Burns. Critical missing piece of information: where did it all start?
Just past the latrine at the parking lot, though, was this helpful sign. TRAIL it proclaimed. Well, that had to be right, we figured. So we locked up the trusty PT Cruiser and set off optimistically into the already hot morning. I knew somewhere in the back of my head that we were looking for a sign that pointed out the split between the North Fork and South Fork trail. So, pretty soon, Kurt and I were excited to find the sign for the North Fork. But where was the South Fork to be found? It seemed we weren’t even on the map yet, so it turned out to be pretty useless. We decided to follow the creek because the other option turned into a road. After another 20 minutes, we figured the trail we were on was just a fishermen’s use trail. So, we about faced, and decided to try our luck along the road, which turned out to head exactly where we wanted to. Another 10 minutes brought us to the sign we were looking for, and we were finally off in the right direction. Great start to the trip: wandering unsure of our direction for an hour. And we were supposed to eventually go cross-country? Uh-oh…
Lesson for future hikers: if you can, just start from the Glacier Lodge, it makes everything super easy. Drop your packs there, bring the car back to “Trailhead Parking,” and walk back along the road. If you decide to start on the trail from the Trailhead Parking lot you’re already on the North Fork trail. You’ll want to hang a left when you see a campsite/picnic area on your left about 15-20 minutes after leaving the parking lot. Cross the bridge just past the picnic area and follow the trail as it angles left off of the road. This will eventually bring you to where the North and South Fork trails diverge. There’ll be a sign there that looks something like this:
The hiking was nice and easy for the first hour or two on the South Fork. We stopped at the wilderness boundary for lunch, as our stomachs were rumbling and it was just before the uphill began ernest. There, we were passed some by trailhead-bound backpackers who had originally set their sights on Mt Sill but turned around. “It’s a f***ing long hike!” they exclaimed, obviously happy to be heading downhill. Fortunately, our approach was a bit shorter than theirs, and we were optimistic as we got back to hiking. The trail was very clear and straightforward, with the only annoyance being the seeming cloud of mosquitoes that descended upon as as we moved past Willow Lake — definitely put on bug spray if the area is at all wet!
Despite being a bit bothered by the altitude, Kurt kept up fine and pretty soon we were at Brainerd Lake. I saw a few cairns, and so we followed these for a bit until they petered out. Instead, we headed up the boulder field and found ourselves at Finger Lake not too long afterwards. For those seeking an easier time, or if you don’t like boulders, there is a reasonably well-used trail all the way from Brainerd Lake to Finger Lake. Personally, I thought the boulders were fun, and good warm-up for the following day. Kurt might disagree with me. Tip: there is a use trail, lightly marked by cairns, which we found on the way down. If you can find this your way will be a little bit easier and minimize the distribution of impact.
We made camp at the north end of Finger Lake, where there are a few great camping areas. There, we ran into Brian, who also had his sights set on Middle Pal. He was planning on going up the “Northeast Face” route detailed in Secor’s guide, and also helpfully illustrated by several trip reports on SummitPost. The route description sounded really similar to ours, except for one critical difference: the start. Porcella and Burns instructs you to go to the far right (west) of the Middle Palisade Glacier. This is wrong. Begin by going up the morraine in the center of the glacier and you’ll be fine. Since Brian was alone, and seemed to know what he was doing, the three of us decided to team up for the trip to the summit.
While we planned on getting up at 6 to make a solid attempt at the summit, Kurt and I both knew that if we wanted to make it back home at a reasonable hour, we didn’t have much of a shot at the summit. No matter, we figured if nothing else, we’d make it to the glacier and then turn around; no reason to waste a beautiful day of hiking in the Sierra. We started up the slabs across the lake (to the west) in the early morning light. We definitely didn’t take the easiest route up (probably 4th class), but it was fairly direct and it managed to let us gain a substantial amount of time on the pair that had left camp about half an hour ahead of us. We saw them take a turn to the right and head for the western-most side of the Middle Pal Glacier (where a large wall separates it from the Norman Clyde Glacier). The day before, we had spoken with them and they had planned on doing the same route we were headed for. Either they were headed for something else, or they messed up their route-finding. In any case, after we had headed in the right direction, we saw them begin their descent.
We finally were ready to turn onto snow (the eastern portion of the Middle Palisade Glacier) at about 10:00. Kurt thought we should turn around. Brian (who turned out to be a great trip-partner) was psyched about continuing, and I wanted to go, too. I asked for another 30 minutes. “I only want to touch the start,” I said, knowing full-well what happens if you give a mouse a cookie. Soon we found ourselves at the base of an unlikely set of ledges. “What if we turn around at 11:30 instead?” I proposed. Kurt was pretty excited to try to reach the summit by now, too (as I had hoped) so before he could change his mind I launched up the 4th class ledge and was around the corner, looking up Secor’s chute. From here on it was sustained, exposed 3rd class climbing. Some of the rock was rotten, and much of it was loose, but careful hand and foot placements meant that I wasn’t raining rocks down upon my followers. I was in heaven. Even when it got windy near the top, I felt great: exhilarated but also completely in control of my head. If only I could feel this way every time I climbed!
We topped out just before our “final turnaround” time of 11:30. The ridge was absolutely incredible. Nothing in front or behind you, except for thousands of feet of air. A knife-edge ridge stretching to left and right. Sun shining. Slight breeze blowing. Just awesome. It is in moments like that in which every negative thought on the way up vanishes. It is memories of that moment that make every sore muscle and blister after the trip seem not so bad at all. That is what keeps me coming back.
As we relaxed and munched on dried mango (protip: always go with Philippine brand) Brian pointed out that had he been leading up the mountain, his self preservation instincts would have turned him around long ago. Fortunately I have repressed most of those instincts. That led to a short discussion of what our mothers would think…I think mine has given up worrying too much, and would be happy to see me happy. Or, at least, she doesn’t let me know she worries too much. Of the three of us, my mom is definitely the most okay with my trips to mountaintops
Now just for the trip down. Always a little trickier than the way up, as the adrenaline ebbs and you’re forced to face the thousand foot drop in front of you. Again, I was just having an awesome time. Kurt and Brian exhaled deeply as we finally made it back to the glacier. There we also saw another pair of climbers’ footprints (and trekking pole imprints). They had, apparently, turned around at the sight of the 4th class climbing. Either that, or they wanted to get home at a reasonable hour. So, out of the three parties attempting Middle Pal that day, we were the only succesful ones.

Heading down the Middle Pal Glacier. You should be able to pick out Kurt and Brian in the larger version.
In any case, Kurt didn’t rest easy for long though, the adventure wasn’t over. I took a few steps on the snow and promptly fell through, fortunately catching myself with my elbows. As my feet dangled over the bergschrund, I dragged myself onto the snow’s surface and rolled a little ways. Silly of me, I thought to myself: the snow had been softened by the warming rock. And if Kurt wasn’t scared of the snowy glacier before, he was now. Other than that, the rest of the trip back was largely uneventful, even if it felt long. Back at Finger Lake, we rested for a little bit, packed up camp, and headed back to the trailhead. Long hours in the car later (Kurt is a champ at long-distance driving), we pulled into Cupertino at about 2:30 in the morning. “See you at work in a few hours,” we said as we parted.
As always, check out the galleries or the flickr set for more, and higher quality, pictures.


















